placeholder coming soon

Comparing Costs: process heat from high-temperature heat pumps and hydrogen

Two technologies dominate the discussion around decarbonizing industrial process heat: direct electrification through high-temperature heat pumps and the use of green hydrogen. 

 

 

What is driving the shift away from fossil fuel process heat? 

Industrial process heat is the single largest energy consumer in German industry, and most of it still comes from natural gas and other fossil fuels. Rising CO₂ prices, growing regulatory pressure and mounting concern over complex energy supply dependencies are pushing industrial companies to explore alternative solutions.

 

Two commercially available technologies dominate the public discussion around decarbonizing process heat: industrial heat pumps and hydrogen. Both play an important role in industrial decarbonization, but that does not make them comparable technologies. They differ fundamentally in how they work, their efficiency, their cost structures and their availability. As a result, broad comparisons between hydrogen and industrial heat pumps often miss important distinctions. A project-specific assessment, however, reveals clear application areas for each technology.

 

This article takes an objective look at both solutions, compares their economics based on reliable data and shows why there is no one-size-fits-all answer.

 

 

What is process heat and why does the 100 to 200°C range matter?

Process heat is the thermal energy required for industrial manufacturing processes, ranging from drying and evaporation to sterilization, melting and firing. Accounting for more than 20% of Germany’s total final energy consumption and approximately two-thirds of final energy consumption in industry, process heat is the single largest energy consumer in German industry.1

 

Temperature requirements vary widely. Paper drying, for example, can take place at temperatures below 200°C, while firing and melting processes in the metals, glass and cement industries require temperatures well above 1,000°C. This article focuses on the 100 to 200°C range because this is where industrial heat pumps and hydrogen compete directly.

 

Today, the vast majority of industrial process heat is still generated using fossil fuels. 2 But the status quo is coming under increasing pressure. Scheduled increases in CO₂ prices, the upcoming European ETS 2 emissions trading system, the phaseout of free emissions allowances, geopolitical shifts in supply chains, excessive dependencies and sustainability initiatives are all making the cost-benefit equation for fossil fuels increasingly unfavorable.

 

Two specific approaches are at the center of the discussion. The first is the direct electrification of process heat using industrial heat pumps. These systems recover waste heat from existing production processes and raise it to the temperature required by the process. The second is the use of green hydrogen, which can be burned directly in place of natural gas or other fossil fuels.

 

Other options for decarbonizing industrial process heat include biomass, electric boilers, solar thermal energy, geothermal energy and direct electrification combined with high-temperature thermal energy storage. Each has its own, in some cases broad, range of applications. Biomass, for example, is well established in the paper, wood and food industries. Electric boilers are considered a standard solution for peak loads and for making electricity consumption more flexible, for example by taking advantage of negative wholesale electricity prices. Solar thermal energy is considered a promising energy-saving option, particularly in sunnier southern regions, while high-temperature thermal storage is becoming increasingly important as a complementary technology for direct electrification.

 

This article, however, focuses specifically on industrial heat pumps and hydrogen because these two approaches feature most prominently in public and policy discussions and compete directly on economics in the 100 to 200°C temperature range. Accordingly, Fraunhofer ISE estimates that, depending on the future scenario considered, high-temperature heat pumps could account for 44% to 64% of process heat generation at temperatures up to 200°C, while hydrogen and gas boilers could account for 7% to 18% in the same temperature range.

 

 

How is heat generated using hydrogen?

There are two basic approaches to generating process heat with hydrogen. The more common approach is direct combustion in adapted burners that use green hydrogen or hydrogen-natural gas blends instead of natural gas. In principle, many existing burners could be converted to operate on hydrogen. Doing so, however, requires modifications to safety, measurement and control systems, as well as additional integration work, such as installing new piping.

 

The second approach is electrochemical conversion, primarily used in hydrogen-powered vehicles. Here, hydrogen is converted back into electricity in a fuel cell. For economic reasons, however, this approach does not play a meaningful role in industrial process heat generation.

 

Hydrogen also varies significantly depending on how it is produced. Common categories include gray, blue and green hydrogen. Gray hydrogen is produced from natural gas through steam reforming and is therefore not carbon-neutral. It is currently the least expensive form of hydrogen. Blue hydrogen is also produced from natural gas, but the resulting CO₂ is captured and stored using carbon capture and storage (CCS). Because it still depends on fossil fuels, blue hydrogen is generally considered a transitional solution.

 

Green hydrogen, produced through electrolysis using renewable electricity, is the only widely used form of hydrogen that is carbon-neutral across the entire production chain. It is therefore the only form of hydrogen compatible with the long-term decarbonization of industrial process heat generation.

 

 

What temperature levels can hydrogen achieve? 

Hydrogen burns at temperatures of up to approximately 2,000°C. Depending on the burner and its design, significantly higher temperatures can also be achieved. In theory, this means that hydrogen can be used for highly demanding high-temperature processes, including melting furnaces in steel production. The high flame temperatures achievable through hydrogen combustion make it particularly attractive for applications where direct electrification reaches technical or economic limits.

 

 

How availabile is green hydrogen and what does it cost?

Over the long term, green hydrogen could offer promising prospects, particularly for demanding high-temperature processes. The current situation, however, is much less encouraging. According to leading economic research institutes, the expansion of hydrogen infrastructure is progressing significantly more slowly than originally planned.3

 

Electrolysis capacity, storage, pipelines and import infrastructure all remain bottlenecks. Renewable electricity generated in Germany or neighboring countries is primarily consumed directly or temporarily stored in large-scale batteries rather than converted into hydrogen. At the same time, large-scale hydrogen import corridors from high-solar-resource regions such as North Africa or southern Spain are not expected to be established before the early 2030s at the earliest.

 

Even then, hydrogen comes with specific transportation and storage requirements that increase costs and may require existing natural gas infrastructure to be retrofitted.

 

According to a discussion paper by the FfE Forschungsstelle für Energiewirtschaft (Research Center for Energy Economics), commissioned by the German Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs, the production cost of green hydrogen in 2025 is 9.80 € per kilogram,4 or approximately 294 €/MWh, based on a higher heating value of approximately 39.4 kWh per kilogram. For comparison, the higher heating value of natural gas is approximately 11.8 to 13.9 kWh per kilogram.

 

Electricity accounts for approximately 50% of total hydrogen costs. Longer-term projections put production costs at around 7.40 € per kilogram, or approximately 222 €/MWh, in 2040. This would represent a significantly smaller price decline over this period than is often expected. Even when considering production costs alone, green hydrogen would therefore remain considerably more expensive over the long term than natural gas is today. The final price paid by industrial customers for natural gas in 2026 is approximately 55 to 80 €/MWh.

 

In its Global Hydrogen Review 2024, the IEA cites a range of $2 to $9 per kilogram. However, this assumes its Net Zero Emissions Scenario, which requires a substantially accelerated global scale-up that has not materialized to date. Supply is further constrained by the fact that only very limited quantities of green hydrogen are currently available.

 

Assessing the actual purchase prices paid by large industrial customers is difficult under current market conditions. A February 2026 study5 by Fraunhofer ISE and consulting firm LBST notes that there is currently no liquid, tradable market for green hydrogen and therefore very little publicly available pricing information for Germany.

 

Data from the European Energy Exchange, voluntarily submitted by companies based on offers and completed transactions, indicate average hydrogen prices of 7.50 to 8.60 € per kilogram, or 225 to 258 €/MWh, between May and July 2025. It remains unclear, however, which companies contributed data, how many participated and what volumes were represented. The study also notes that the hydrogen involved was likely not primarily renewable hydrogen of non-biological origin.

 

For industrial investment planning, this means that if the hydrogen market does scale up as expected, buyers will likely need to plan for several years of comparatively high and volatile prices, along with significant regional differences in availability.

 

 

How is process heat generated using industrial heat pumps?

Industrial heat pumps use available waste heat from sources such as production processes, cooling circuits and exhaust air as a heat source for process heat generation. In a closed thermodynamic cycle, the heat pump uses refrigerants and compression to raise this heat to a higher, usable temperature level before supplying it as process heat or process steam.

 

When the required temperature lift between the heat source and heat sink is particularly large, systems often use two-stage compression with two separate refrigerant circuits. This configuration makes it possible to achieve demanding temperature lifts.

 

 

What temperature levels can industrial heat pumps achieve? 

Modern industrial heat pumps such as the VQ180 (formerly SPH‘s ThermBooster™) can provide process steam at temperatures of up to approximately 200°C. Target temperatures of up to 180°C are considered particularly attractive from an economic standpoint and cover a large share of industrial applications.

 

In addition to compressor technology and heat exchangers, selecting the appropriate refrigerant is a key factor in system performance and efficiency. Synthetic refrigerants typically cover temperature ranges up to approximately 165°C, while hydrocarbons are often used as refrigerants at higher temperatures. A separate article addresses refrigerant selection criteria for industrial heat pumps in detail.

 

 

Are industrial heat pumps commercially ready and cost-competitive?

Industrial heat pumps are already commercially available for applications between 100 and 200°C, as demonstrated by the growing number of reference systems operating in production environments across a wide range of industries.

 

In many applications, they are also already cost-competitive with energy sources such as natural gas, which for many years had few economically viable alternatives. A well-founded total cost of ownership (TCO) analysis that considers the system’s full operating life and realistically accounts for rising CO₂ prices further strengthens the economic case for industrial heat pumps.

 

Compared with green hydrogen, industrial heat pumps can operate significantly more economically in many applications. One key reason is the level of efficiency they can achieve, which we examine in more detail below.

 

 

Hydrogen vs. heat pumps: how do efficiency and cost compare?

Industrial heat pumps convert electricity into process heat far more efficiently than hydrogen pathways do, once the full energy conversion chain from electrolysis through combustion is accounted for.

 

placeholder-big-feature

What happens to 100 kWh of electricity under each pathway?

Figure 1 shows how much useful heat can be generated from 100 kWh of electricity under the specified conditions.

 

  1. Assumptions Used for the Comparison
    • System boundary for the energy comparison: 100 kWh of electrical final energy at the site. Upstream electricity grid losses are not included because they apply equally, in principle, to electrolysis, direct electrification and heat pumps.Hydrogen: All H₂ energy values are based on the lower heating value (LHV). A reference efficiency of 65% LHV is used for PEM/alkaline electrolysis. The H₂ boiler is assumed to operate at 90% LHV efficiency. The energy Sankey diagram should show a separate loss band for processing, compression, storage and transportation. Because the magnitude of these losses depends heavily on the supply pathway, they should not be presented as a universal value.Direct electrification: Electric boiler/electric heater with 98% efficiency. The IEA likewise uses 98% for industrial electric boilers.High-temperature heat pump: COP range of 2 to 5, with a reference value of COP 3. The additional useful heat comes from industrial waste heat or another heat source.

 

Sources Important: Some values are intentionally used as modeling assumptions and are not taken directly from a specific source.

 

    • German Environment Agency (UBA) / Fraunhofer IEG / Fraunhofer ISI – H₂ vs. heat pump comparison:This is the source of the original figure shown above. The UBA uses an efficiency range of 51–83% for hydrogen production, 90% for gas/H₂ boilers, and a seasonal performance factor (SPF) of 3 for air-source heat pumps. Based on these assumptions, it calculates that H₂ and synthetic methane require four to five times as much electricity.
    • U.S. DOE – PEM electrolysis: System efficiency on an LHV basis: 61% current status, 65% target, and 72% ultimate target. This provides solid support for our reference value of 65% LHV.
    • U.S. DOE – alkaline electrolysis: Comparable efficiency levels. DOE data confirm that approximately 60–70% LHV at the system level is a reasonable range for alkaline electrolyzers.
    • U.S. DOE – SOEC/high-temperature electrolysis: This is important when considering the upper end of the efficiency range. SOEC can achieve significantly higher electrical efficiency but requires an external high-temperature heat input. SOEC should therefore not be directly compared with PEM or alkaline electrolysis based solely on electrical energy input.
    • IEA – industrial electric boilers: The IEA assumes an efficiency of 98% for industrial electric boilers, providing direct support for the value used in our direct electrification scenario.
    • IEA Heat Pumping Technologies, Annex 58 – high-temperature heat pumps: Annex 58 specifically addresses industrial high-temperature heat pumps (HTHPs) operating above 100°C, including applications up to approximately 200°C. A recent HPT example reports COPs of 2.8–4.0 for typical industrial applications with heat-source temperatures of approximately 40 to 60°C and process heat temperatures of 100 to 200°C, with higher COPs possible at smaller temperature lifts. Another development project targeting 200°C reports a COP above 3.5 with a heat-source temperature of 95°C.
    • COP 2–5 in our graphic: This is intentionally a broad illustrative range rather than a range taken from a single study. A COP of 3 is a reasonable reference value for the graphic. COP 2 represents challenging applications with large temperature lifts, while COP 4–5 represents more favorable heat-source conditions and smaller temperature lifts. For typical applications in the 100 to 200°C range, this is scientifically more defensible than using a blanket COP of 6.
    • H₂ processing / transportation / storage = 95%: This is currently an illustrative assumption, not a universally applicable value supported by a single source. Energy requirements can vary considerably depending on pressure level, pipeline or trailer transportation, storage method, and distance. I would therefore either explicitly label this value in the graphic as “95% – illustrative assumption” or show this step as a range.

 

 

What are themarket and policy trends shaping hydrogen and heat pump adoption? 

Where does hydrogen scale-up stand in Europe, China and the United States?

 

Policy targets for both electrification and the expansion of the hydrogen economy are ambitious. While electrification efforts are lagging behind their targets, the hydrogen economy is facing even greater challenges.

 

Germany’s National Hydrogen Strategy calls for 10 GW of domestic electrolysis capacity by 2030.6 Currently, however, installed electrolysis capacity stands at only approximately 181 MW.

 

An analysis by the Institute of Energy Economics at the University of Cologne (EWI) concludes that Germany is likely to miss its 2030 target.7 If all projects announced through 2030 are included, and assuming every one of them is actually completed, total electrolysis capacity would reach 8.7 GW. Among the projects analyzed, however, more than 20 were announced for commissioning in 2026, and 14 of those had not yet received final financing commitments. Several major hydrogen projects have since been postponed or canceled.

 

This does not necessarily mean that Germany’s hydrogen scale-up will fail. It does suggest, however, that the expansion is likely to proceed much more slowly and unevenly than initially projected.

 

The development of electrolysis capacity across the EU relative to policy targets requires a more nuanced analysis than can be covered in this article. Broadly speaking, however, the trend is similar to that in Germany.

 

As part of its hydrogen strategy, the EU has set a target of 40 GW of electrolysis capacity by 2030. Data on currently installed capacity across the EU remain limited, but according to Germany’s Federal Institute for Geosciences and Natural Resources,8 installed capacity in the EU-28 amounted to 859 MW in 2023. According to Fraunhofer ISI,9 other analyses indicate that approximately 120 GW of electrolysis capacity would actually be required to meet European hydrogen production targets. Reaching that level would require installed electrolysis capacity to increase by nearly a factor of 900.

 

The United States also established ambitious targets for expanding green hydrogen under the Inflation Reduction Act. Those targets came under pressure following the change in administration in 2025. The elimination or restructuring of key incentive programs has led to project cancellations and a broader slowdown in capacity additions.

 

China, by contrast, dominates the global electrolyzer market. According to the IEA’s Global Hydrogen Review 2025, approximately 1.3 GW of electrolysis capacity was installed in China by the end of 2024, representing around 65% of global capacity. Producing the least expensive green hydrogen in China costs approximately 40% to 45% less than in Europe or the United States. This is primarily due to lower electricity prices resulting from lower capital expenditures and financing costs for renewable energy projects.

 

How are hydrogen and electricity prices expected to trend?

 

Given the slow pace of hydrogen market development, it is not surprising that projected green hydrogen prices span an unusually wide range. This is true even though electricity accounts for approximately 50% of hydrogen production costs and relatively robust electricity price forecasts are available.

 

While the most optimistic scenarios suggest that hydrogen prices of 2 to 3 € per kilogram could be achievable from 2030 onward, more realistic analyses project significantly higher levels. The FfE, for example, concludes that the complex installation of electrolyzers, project development costs, stack replacements and regulatory requirements governing electricity procurement are generally more costly than many optimistic analyses assume.

 

As a result, the number of economically viable applications for green hydrogen decreases. This, in turn, reduces total hydrogen production volumes and is likely to place further upward pressure on prices. When planning investments, companies should therefore ideally work with hydrogen price ranges rather than isolated price points. A project-specific analysis is also essential.

 

The economics of heat pumps likewise depend directly on the energy source they use,  in this case industrial electricity prices. Over the medium to long term, there are reasons for cautious optimism. The continued and increasingly rapid expansion of renewable energy is reducing the marginal cost of electricity generation. Onsite power generation, which is becoming increasingly economically attractive, and long-term power purchase agreements (PPAs) can also reduce energy costs substantially.

 

At the same time, the electrification of numerous industrial sectors, transportation and heating will require significant investment in the power grid, including investments aimed at avoiding costly redispatch measures during periods of excess renewable generation. Overall, however, electricity prices offer more realistic opportunities for cost stabilization, with significantly narrower ranges of uncertainty.

 

What policy mechanisms support each technology?

 

Policy over the coming years is placing a much stronger emphasis on electrification. Key elements include Germany’s Federal Funding for Energy and Resource Efficiency in the Economy (EEW), the European Union’s heat pump strategy, and the Heat Auction.

 

Hydrogen is also supported through instruments such as Germany’s Carbon Contracts for Difference. The central challenge, however, is likely to be less about supply-side support and more about the combination of limited or weak demand, high costs and delays in infrastructure development.

 

There is another important consideration. Even if green hydrogen becomes available in larger quantities and at more attractive prices, it is likely to be prioritized for sectors that simply cannot be decarbonized through other means, including parts of the chemical, cement and steel industries.

 

For applications in which industrial heat pumps are technically viable, heat pumps are therefore likely to remain the preferred option from both a policy and economic perspective.

 

placeholder-big-featureHow does the cost of process heat compare between hydrogen and heat pumps?

Figure 2 compares the cost of generating process heat using hydrogen and high-temperature heat pumps under the specified conditions. In both cases, the price of electricity is a key cost factor.

 

Sources and Assumptions

  • Industrial electricity prices in Europe: Eurostat, dataset nrg_pc_205. In H2 2025, the EU average for non-household customers in the 500–2,000 MWh/year consumption band was €183.7/MWh. Finland was at €74.8/MWh, while Ireland was at €255.2/MWh. These figures support our illustrative electricity price range of €80–200/MWh.
  • Direct electrification: The IEA assumes an efficiency of 98% for industrial electric boilers.
  • Hydrogen production costs: FfE, “From Theory to Practice: Why Green Hydrogen Is More Expensive Than Expected.” The analysis estimates more realistic production costs of approximately €9.80/kg in the near term and €7.40/kg in 2040.
  • Hydrogen plausibility check: ACER estimates current average production costs for renewable hydrogen in Europe at approximately €8/kg.
  • Hydrogen network: Germany’s Federal Network Agency (Bundesnetzagentur) has set a ramp-up tariff of €25/kWh/h/year for firm annual capacity on the hydrogen core network.
  • €5/kg H₂: This is not a current market price, but our deliberately optimistic low-cost scenario at the plant gate. It is below ACER’s current estimated production costs and should be explicitly identified as such.

 

 

So are heat pumps or hydrogen more cost effective? 

Based on the assumptions used here, , heat pumps deliver lower variable heat costs than hydrogen even under deliberately unfavorable heat pump conditions paired with optimistic hydrogen prices. Despite the assumptions underlying htese example calculations, the overall picture is clear: as an energy carrier for industrial process heat, green hydrogen is inherently less efficient than a high-temperature heat pump. When the entire energy conversion chain is considered, overall efficiency clearly favors the heat pump.

 

But what does this mean for the actual cost of heat? Green hydrogen price forecasts continue to span a wide range because many key questions surrounding availability and production costs remain unresolved. According to our calculations, however, the variable cost of heat from hydrogen remains higher than that of a heat pump even when deliberately unfavorable assumptions are used for the high-temperature heat pump and deliberately optimistic hydrogen prices are assumed.

 

Ultimately, however, a meaningful comparison requires project-specific system design. Process temperatures and load profiles, heat-source conditions, site-specific factors and other variables affecting cost and efficiency determine how economically viable a solution will actually be.

 

This is exactly where support matters most. Industrial partners receive advise and support on the path toward economical, future-ready process heat generation, from the initial assessment and technical system design through to a fully operational system.

 

 

FAQs

Is hydrogen or a heat pump better for very high-temperature processes above 200°C?

Hydrogen can reach flame temperatures of up to approximately 2,000°C, which makes it suitable for demanding high-temperature processes such as melting furnaces in steel production. Industrial heat pumps, by contrast, currently reach up to approximately 200°C, so hydrogen remains the more viable option where direct electrification reaches technical or economic limits.

 

Why does green hydrogen cost so much more than natural gas today?

Production costs for green hydrogen were approximately 9.80 € per kilogram in 2025, or about 294 €/MWh, while industrial customers pay roughly 55 to 80 €/MWh for natural gas in 2026. Electricity accounts for approximately 50% of hydrogen production costs, and limited electrolysis capacity, storage, and import infrastructure keep prices elevated.

 

Can existing gas infrastructure be reused for hydrogen or heat pumps?

Many existing burners could in principle be converted to run on hydrogen, though this requires modifications to safety, measurement, and control systems along with additional piping work. Heat pumps, by comparison, do not rely on combustion infrastructure at all, instead recovering and upgrading waste heat already present at the site.

 

 

[1] German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt): Energy consumption for fossil and renewable heat. https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/daten/umweltzustand-trends/energie/energieverbrauch-fuer-fossile-erneuerbare-waerme (available only in German)

 

[2] EE4InG: Stellungnahme des Forschungsnetzwerks Energie - Industrie und Gewerbe: Dialog Klimaneutrale Wärme, position paper on industrial heat. https://ee4ing.de/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/U-20210423_Stellungnahme_Industriewaerme.pdf (available only in German)

 

[3] Verkehrsrundschau: Wasserstoff in Deutschland 2026: Infrastruktur wächst, Kosten bremsen - Hydrogen in Germany 2026—infrastructure expansion and cost constraints. https://www.verkehrsrundschau.de/nachrichten/vermischtes/wasserstoff-in-deutschland-2026-infrastruktur-waechst-kosten-bremsen-3788416 (available only in German)

 

[4] Research Center for Energy Economics (FfE): Discussion paper on electrolyzer investment costs. English abstract: https://www.ffe.de/en/publications/between-expectation-and-reality-how-can-the-hydrogen-market-ramp-up-be-shaped/ 

 

[5] Fraunhofer ISE and LBST: Facts and parameter analysis on hydrogen supply in Baden-Württemberg, February 2026. https://www.e-mobilbw.de/fileadmin/media/e-mobilbw/Publikationen/Studien/e-mobil-BW_Fakten_und_Parameteranalyse_zur_Wasserstoffversorgung_Baden-Wuerttembergs_2026.pdf (available only in German)

 

[6] German Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs: National Hydrogen Strategy. https://www.bundeswirtschaftsministerium.de/Navigation/EN/hydrogen/home.html 

 

[7] Institute of Energy Economics at the University of Cologne (EWI): Analysis of electrolysis capacity through 2030. https://www.ewi.uni-koeln.de/en/news/only-1-5-gw-of-electrolysis-capacity-secured-by-2030/ 

 

[8] German Federal Institute for Geosciences and Natural Resources (BGR): Hydrogen market availability. https://www.bgr.bund.de/EN/Themen/Rohstoffe/Energierohstoffe/Wasserstoff/Marktverfuegbarkeit_Wasserstoff_en/marktverfuegbarkeit_wasserstoff_node_en.html 

 

[9] Fraunhofer ISI: Hydrogen facts. https://websites.fraunhofer.de/isi/projekte/h2-fakten/ (available only in German)